Poochyena Power! - Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Red Rescue Team

Previous

Day 18: Wherein Joat demonstrates that silence is pyrite.


image

Joat: … … …Again.

And again, and again, and again…

That’s not a silhouette. That’s blinking translucency.

image

Joat: Oh? It’s saying something! But… I can’t quite make it out… It’s clearer than it was before, but…

I’ll try talking to it.

I’d ask why he expects this to work, since talking generally makes the other end of the conversation harder to hear rather than easier, but we’re working by dream logic here, so…

image

Joat: Hello. Please tell me. You… Who are you?

Judging by the naming conventi… Okay, I think you know the drill by now.

image: …I am…

…all I am all I am.

image: I am Gardevoir.

image

Joat: Ga-Gardevoir…?!

image

Gardevoir: I’m so glad. Finally… I finally got to meet you…

image

Joat: …? Finally met me…? You knew me from before? What about me?

“Met” implies a first-time encounter. Is this a translation error, or something?

image

Gardevoir: I am your…

…Creepy stalker?

image

Joat: I want to know more… No… It’s fading… … …

The next morning…

You keep using that term, which makes me wonder how boring your normal dreams must be.

image

Joat: It’s the dream I always have, but it was clearer than it was before… I think I finally learned who that Pokémon was… That’s it! Gardevoir! It was Gardevoir! Yesterday, Whiscash said…

image

Whiscash: Yes, a human. As one might expect, the human that grabbed the tail was subject to a curse of a thousand years. However, just as the curse was cast, a Pokémon named Gardevoir shielded the human… And sacrificed herself to absorb the curse.

image

Cherithe: Why? Why would that Pokémon, Gardevoir, take the human’s place?

image

Whiscash: To Gardevoir, that human was her partner. There exist strong bonds between humans and Pokémon.

image

Joat: …Maybe… Maybe, I… Maybe I was the human who was Gardevoir’s partner…

If I were in that situation, if I figured the dreams were in any way prophetic (and they are way too coherent to not be), I would not be using the term “maybe.” I mean, the evidence looks decently clear, here (provided we do count the use of the term “met” as a translation error), and there aren’t really any other plausible explanations floating about.

image

Joat: Maybe I was the one who abandoned Gardevoir when she was cursed… Maybe that’s why I turned into a Pokémon…

image

Cherithe: …Oh? You look pale. Is something the matter?

How?

image

Cherithe: Well, anyway. As always, let’s try to do our best!

image

Cherithe: Oh, yeah!

image

Cherithe: When I was on the way here, I think there was a commotion at Pokémon Square.

Yesterday, Cherithe walked off to the left, implying her home is that way. Did she really take that big of a detour on the way here?

image

Cherithe: I wonder if something happened…

Why are you leaving all of my stuff completely unguarded, Kangaskhan?

image

Cherithe: The town’s atmosphere is different somehow…

image

Cherithe: Maybe something happened.

Zombie apocolypse, perhaps?

image

Cherithe: Joat, let’s check it out!.

image

Bellsprout: Let me tell you, I was amazed! It really was true!

image

Cherithe: What was true?

image

Bellsprout: The NInetales legend! I never believed the rumors, so you can bet I was shocked to learn the truth!

image

Caterpie: Joat, Cherithe.

image

Cherithe: Oh, hi, Caterpie.

image

Cherithe: Even you came out, Caterpie?

Why is that a surprise? Caterpie is clearly an outdoorsy type. As are most Pokémon, I imagine.

image

Snubbull: Ssh! Quiet. That guy there’s telling us. Keep it down.

image

Cherithe: Huh? Who’s talking

image

Caterpie: I-it’s…

Caterpie, if you’re that scared of Gengar, why not just hear the story second-hand. Or… second… whatever those stubby things you have are called.

image

Gengar: …So, I went up to the Hill of the Ancients.

For absolutely no explained reason.

image

Gengar: And that’s where I saw it! It was shocking stuff, I tell you! Kekeh!

image

Lombre: Shocking stuff?

image

Gengar: This certain Pokémon was getting advice from Xatu.

image

Gengar: That Pokémon… It looks like an ordinary Pokémon…

image

Gengar: But get this! It was originally a human!

Huh. So the Xatu used to be human. Who knew?

image

Bellsprout: What?!

image

Snubbull: It really existed… A human that turned into a Pokémon.

image

Gengar: There’s more. Xatu told the human… That how the human became a Pokémon has a lot to do with how the world’s balance is upset.

image

Lombre: Wait a second… That’s exactly like the NInetales legend!

image

Gengar: Kekeh! Don’t be too shocked yet. There’s more.

image

Gengar: You all know how there’ve been many natural disasters, correct?

…Kiiiinda hard to miss.

image

Gengar: According to Xatu, those disasters are caused by the world’s balance being upset. And if the world’s balance isn’t restored soon…

image

Gengar: The unthinkable will happen to the world! That’s what Xatu said! Kekeh!

image

Lombre: Wh-what?

image

Bellsprout: The world… The unthinkable’s going to happen?

image

Snubbull: What are we to do?!

image

Cherithe: That Gengar…! He’s deliberately working everyone up…

True, but he hasn’t told a single lie thus far. And honestly, I think this is important stuff to know, even if expressed for the wrong reason, in this case.

Honestly, if we’d told everyone the tale like we probably should have done, we probably could have nipped this in the bud.

image

Gengar: Now, now, people. There’s no need to panic.

It’s only the destruction of the world, after all!

image

Gengar: Why, I think there’s a way we can do something about this. Kekeh!

image

Snubbull: Wh-what can we do?

image

Gengar: Oh, it’s quite simple, actually. If the world’s balance is upset by a human becoming a Pokémon…

image

Gengar: Then, if that human is gone, then everything should return to normal, correct?

In Teen Titans, I remember an episode where Raven and Terra were arguing about whether or not to destroy a console. If memory serves, Terra wanted to destroy it, thinking that doing so would stop the process of a bad thing happening. Raven wanted not to destroy it, since they might be destroying their only way to stop the process.

Now, I was with Terra on that one, since a console you don’t know how to use is pretty much useless anyway, but the point is, if they get rid of that former human and it turns out they’re the only one who can stop it, the world’s kinda screwed.

image

Lombre: Th-that’s true!

image

Snubbull: When you put it that way… maybe you’re right.

image

Gengar: Kekeh! And that human is the rotten coward that abandoned Gardevoir, correct?

image

Gengar: I don’t think the human can complain about anything if we get rid of it.

image

Gengar: Isn’t that right, Joat?

image

Lombre: Who… What?! It… It can’t be!

image

Bellsprout: Y-you… You were that human?!

image

Snubbull: Is that true? Hey!

Ah yes, I guess I can understand why you would think I was the coward who did that.

For that matter, didn’t these incidents start before my arrival? I mean, I don’t think it was ever stated, but it was at the very least strongly implied.

image

Cherithe: W-w-wait… This is, like… There’s a good explanation for…

image

Snubbull: We’re not asking you, we’re asking Joat!

Ah, yes, time to clear my name!

image

Snubbull: Hey! Joat! So what is it?!

…Oh, right, silent protagonist, crap…

image

Cherithe: Joat…

image

Caterpie: Joat…

image

Gengar: Kekekekekekeh! Looks like you have nothing to say in your defense, Joat!

image

Gengar: That’s how it is, fellow Pokémon.

image

Gengar: Let’s get rid of Joat and regain peace. Kekekekekeh!

image

Cherithe: Wh-what? E-everyone, what’s gotten into you? What are you going to do?

image

Lombre: Joat, forgive me!

I just missed getting a screenshot of it, but Lombre attacked with a fierce punch which, well, missed. And then the other Pokémon close in for the attack, taking their sweet time with actually attacking.

image

Cherithe: Wah! What are you doing?!

I think it’s rather clear. I mean, what did you expect them to do, if their plan was to get rid of the human in question? Give him the keys to a shiny new spaceship and kindly tell him to go to Mars?

image

Cherithe: Waaaaah! Joat, run!

image

Gengar: Serves them right! Kekekekeh!

image

Cherithe: I never expected anyone to attack us like that.

“Us”?

image

Cherithe: But listen, Joat.

image

Cherithe: Why didn’t you say anything? Why didn’t you argue that it’s not you?!

Ugh… Okay, no jokes about this one. Instead, a bit of a rant.

Remember what I said at the beginning, about the game not knowing what they want to do with the protagonist? There’s a reason why the protagonist in the main series games is silent. It’s so they don’t say something the player would not say, or in a way the player would not say it, and such is a good way to go about things, otherwise this happens.

This game, by the quiz at the beginning, clearly wants me to be able to put myself into the role of this character, but even if I were 100% convinced that I was guilty of dooming the entire planet, I would never say either of those things. Not even close. Nowadays, I would just come right out and state my suspicions. When I was 10, I’m not sure what I would have done, but unless I planned to heroically sacrifice my life to potentially save the world, I’m pretty sure I would not want to go it alone. Even way back then, I understood the concept of safety in numbers.

With the thing before, with the character not speaking, I could at least see myself locking up under such a situation or something like that, but with this…

*sigh* Well, I guess I’ll choose the first option.

image

Cherithe: Wh-what’s the matter? What makes you say that all the sudden?

The script.

image

Cherithe: Give up our rescue team? It’s not like you to say that, Joat.

Say what you will about how I wouldn’t say that, but honestly, I think that it’s a logical thing to do. It’s kind of hard to maintain a rescue team when you are a wanted fugitive.

image

Cherithe: Is something the matter?

You mean other than the story yesterday and me being nearly beaten by a mob just now?

I mean, for crying out loud, say what you will about whether I should be the leader of a rescue team, but my Run Away ability was pretty darn vital back there…

Well, that, or I could have pointed out that we recently took down Zapdos. I mean, would you want to mess with that team?

image

Cherithe: …Huh? You had a dream? And Gardevoir appeared in it?

“And you were there, and you, and you…”

image

Cherithe: …And that made you think that maybe you were that human after all…

image

Cherithe: …So that’s what it is. That’s what happened…

image

Cherithe: Listen, Joat. Did your dream make you remember what you were like as a human being? Since it didn’t, you don’t know what really happened.

Much as I appreciate the sentiment, were I in that position, I do not think that would be a very convincing argument.

image

Cherithe: I… I have faith in you, Joat. You know that? So…

image

Alakazam: After that scene in Pokémon Square… We held a town meeting… On what we must do to save the world… And we arrived at a consensus. We must get rid of you.

This is actually fairly dark. I mean, consider the target demographic. Sure, I was 25 at time of original writing, but the target demographic is about 10. And though they haven’t outright stated it, I kinda doubt they plan to simply make the former human faint.

In short, for most of the people playing this game at the time, the town has unanimously decided to murder a small child. Without conclusive proof, at that.

image

Cherithe: You’re kidding!

image

Alakazam: I was incredulous too… I had hoped it would not come to this, but… It is unfortunate. We will… Defeat you with all our might!

image

Cherithe: (W-we’re fighting here…?)

image

Alakazam: We will give you tonight.

image

Cherithe: Huh?

image

Alakazam: Pack your supplies and get out of here.

It’s a good thing I’m pretty well-prepared for travel, considering that all of my supplies that aren’t already packed are, well, in town.

image

Alakazam: Come tomorrow, rescue teams of all sorts will take up the chase… And attack you without hesitation.

Are you and the rest of the town set on this or not? I mean, I could understand if only this team are sparing them for now, delaying and only later going out to save face, but apparently all of the rescue teams agreed to this.

Either you are fully certain that Joat is the cause of all this, in which case you are endangering the entire world (at which point Joat would die along with the rest of the world, for that matter), or you aren’t and therefore shouldn’t be attacking Joat yet, instead perhaps imprisoning them and trying to figure out the truth while you have them in containment. Or, if you’re really desperate, kill Joat right now. Either way, you are either delayed in killing Joat, during which time the disasters are still going on, thus making this objectively worse than just killing him now, or you are letting him get away, but wasting a whole bunch of resources trying to find him again, making this objectively worse than doing nothing at all.

image

Alakazam: And not just you. Anyone that goes with Joat will be considered an enemy. The trackers will attack without mercy. That goes for us too. We will join the hunt to be rid of you.

Against all odds, you must run. Run, run… And survive. You must run till you discover the truth.

So you’re reasonably certain that we’re innocent, and… Actually, I take it back. Even keeping up appearances isn’t an excuse. First off, unless you have an audience nearby, if you meet up with Team Zephyrai, you can simply “fail” to apprehend them, and secondly, if you’re reasonably certain I’m not guilty, why did you not speak up? And if you did, why didn’t they listen? Are they seriously taking the hearsay of a team called Team Meanies over the word of a well-respected gold-rank team whose leader is explicitly stated to be very knowledgeable? Wouldn’t that at least give the town pause for thought?

image

Cherithe: Alakazam…

image

Alakazam: There will be no mercy the next time we meet. Farewell.

image

Cherithe: In their own way, Alakazam’s team has faith in you too.

In their own incredibly confusing and nonsensical way.

image

Cherithe: Didn’t I say this before? I’m not going to worry anymore. Whatever happens, I’ll always have faith in you, Joat. Even if we’re attacked by other teams, I won’t be scared.

image

Cherithe: What good will it do if you don’t believe in yourself, Joat?

image

Cherithe: Caterpie…

image

Caterpie: Joat… I made a promise, remember? That we would make a rescue team base here. That I would join your rescue team when I grew up. Joat… Don’t give up. You’re a hero to me, Joat. I believe in you too, Joat.

If they’re only superficially going to give the player options, why not just have the character speak up without having the player select an option? I mean, these aren’t even really different flavors of affirmation. I could at least understand it if one of the options were something like “Alright… I’ll try my best.” At least then, you’re doing some role-playing, because one option sounds confident and the other sounds a bit more uncertain and scared. Which, let’s face it, would describe me through pretty much the entirety of this adventure.

image

Cherithe: Yeah! That’s right! That’s more like it! That’s what we expect from our Joat!

image

Cherithe: We’ll have to leave for the time being… But let’s be sure to come back! And we’ll bring the truth back with us!

And also probably large sums of cash, because that’s generally how this sort of thing goes.

Next