The King of Demons
Well, well, well. This chapter has a lot to talk about, doesn’t it? Unfortunately, I don’t really want to say a whole lot.
It’s not for lack of material. Every character with a name is worth discussing, the plot itself is ambiguous, and the themes are pervasive. But instead, I want to discuss why I could have so much discussion over this chapter. Let’s talk about ambiguity.
In this story, ambiguity is not omnipresent. This isn’t Silent Hill (at first); most of the plot elements are clear as day. Some of the characters, mostly unnamed ones like the king, are obvious pastiches of JRPG NPCs. However, there are two lines of dialogue that change the entire story depending on their interpretation.
The first is Hash’s “That was NOT the Demon!” and the second is Straybow’s “All of my emotions exploded!” One of these lines has to be false. If they were both true, then neither the Demon King nor Straybow could have kidnapped Alicia. So, is Hash mistaken about not killing the Demon King or is Straybow covering up how he planned this from the beginning?
I don’t want to try and tear this plot apart to find out what “really” happened. Whichever conclusion you reach is probably more interesting to you, and that’s more important.
I do want to point out a few things I know about, but didn’t mention for the sake of tone or pacing. The font-changing during Brando’s speech at the end of the chapter is not present in the Japanese version. I really like this change because it compensates for a common problem in SNES RPGs. Since they lack any kind of “acting,” it’s can make dialogue hard to parse. It’s not always obvious how a certain line would be said. By using different fonts, Aeon Genesis adds inflection. It’s what puts the scene over for me.
I really like Brando’s speeches during both of his chapters. He’s able to stay sympathetic in my mind while murdering every human to ever exist. He gets really close to full-tilt edgelord, but he never crosses over. The fact that his anger is born of trauma helps, but his dialogue alone is more interesting than edgy to me. I also like some of the words of encouragement he gives to the bosses. In particular, “That’s right, you’re the strongest!” stood out to me as weirdly innocent sounding. He can’t show love to another human, but he can show kindness to his weird anti-humanity brigade. Brando is such a weirdly compelling character.
What do you all think? How did you interpret the plot and its characters? Is Brando sympathetic to you, or am I being to soft on him? And, if I can be self-indulgent, if you weren’t familiar with this story, did I get ya? Did something I do give away the twist too early, or you were as taken aback as I was when I first played this?
I’m getting anxious about finishing up this LP, but I don’t want to close the poll just yet. This is kind of an important poll, so I don’t want to close it before everyone has a chance to catch up and vote. I’ll leave it open until tomorrow afternoon, probably around 5 p.m. EST. I want to keep it open for at least the rest of the day, but I won’t be able to start working on the update until tomorrow afternoon anyways.