What if YIIK was a Marvel Film? Let's Dunk on Dustborn

Summary

CasualTalk: The first five minutes of this is the cast doing an actual play of a fake D&D knockoff.

CasualTalk: It’s really funny because Eli’s VA is the only one even trying and the rest are phoning it in.

: She’s playing a shield build? Those are terrible! Armor class doesn’t scale well and the damage bonuses aren’t going to outweigh using a two-hander.

: What did you expect from the character whose defining trait is having a mental breakdown?

CasualTalk: Ziggy teleports to try and see behind the screen and there’s a joke about how Eli predicted that and is using his illusions on all his sheets.

CasualTalk: I used to straight up give my players the stats for everything once they landed hits on it because it made combat go way faster.

CasualTalk: The bus breaks down for.. how many times has this been now that the bus has broken down?

: This is at least the third.

: “Can we keep driving?”

: “Are you okay with the bus potentially catching on fire?”

: “Under different circumstances I might say ‘yes’, but since we’re in a rush and trying to fly under the radar.. so how do we fix it?”

: “We reattach the shield.. but I don’t have the tools.”

: “We passed a station a couple miles back. Ziggy, we might find what we need there.”

: “All right. The rest of us can stretch our legs while we wait-”

: “Hey, let’s check out that house over there? It looks abandoned.”

: “You’d get along well with Pax’s mom, Sol.”

: “The one who fought alongside the Wildflowers? I’m sure I would.”

: “My Tia had a farm. I’d help her take care of the goats. If I did a good job, she’d play football with me. Great playground for a ten year old.”

CasualTalk: The front door is nailed shut. Just keep that in mind.

CasualTalk: To progress, we need the girl to summon a WMV so we can use it to explode the basement door.

: He’s not about to do what I think he is.. is he?

: Points of Pythagoras, that’s not safe! Never use a gas generator indoors! That could kill me, and if it can kill me, it can definitely kill you!

: This Ragnar really is a complete idiot!

: Don’t listen, Ragnar. Start that gas generator inside. Put it in your living room, and don’t forget to close all the doors and windows. You don’t want to waste that heat, do you?

CasualTalk: This scene is kind of a microcosm of everything wrong with this game. There’s really only three explanations for how this got here, and none of them are good.

CasualTalk: Explanation one is that Ragnar wrote this scene not knowing how a gas generator works. He didn’t bother doing even the smallest amount of research. No one at Red Thread apparently knew either, because they’d probably have stopped him if they did.

CasualTalk: Explanation two is that Ragnar didn’t write that, but it came about as the result of something done by someone else. This is still bad because he should have known this shit and had them take it out.

CasualTalk: The third explanation is the one I kind of hope is real. The third explanation is that someone at Red Thread, who knew fully well that the game was doomed, put this in to see if they could get it past Ragnar.

CasualTalk: I haven’t forgotten Sam Porter Bridges.

CasualTalk: Do you remember how, maybe five minutes ago, Pax said the door was nailed shut?

CasualTalk: CONTINUITY. TRACKER. It’s not hard!

: “Doesn’t look like anyone’s lived here for YEARS.”

: “Whoever they were, I hope they smoked. I’m fresh out and irritable.”

: “Oh…”

: Is her lip filler going to explode?

CasualTalk: I haven’t pointed it out much, but this game’s cutscene direction sucks. These feel like YIIK cutscenes.

CasualTalk: Yeah, this game really is painful.

CasualTalk: We need to rip the WMV out of Amy Winehouse. It’s funny how the WMVs have enough power to break through walls but don’t make her head explode.

: “Are the voices gone?”

: “They are, but.. there’s still PAIN. So much pain…”

CasualTalk: I didn’t immediately recognize the poem here, and that’s because it’s by an Australian poet named Dorothea Mackellar. She died in 1968.

: “That’s… BETTER. Not GONE. But better. Thank you.”

: “I thought the ECHOES were being pulled back to the epicenter, to the Tree-?”

: “The Tree. They are. I don’t know why these Echoes.. ATTACKED her.”

: “I should leave.”

: “Leave and go WHERE?”

: “Away. From you. From HER. It’s not safe. I’m dangerous.”

: “Whoa, hold on, you want to LEAVE us? That’s NOT happening, I’m not-”

: “Let’s not make any RASH decisions and talk this through first.”

: “Listen, kid, find somewhere to lie down. Take the girl with you, she’ll let us know if you need anything. Alright?”

: “Not exactly. They both ATTRACT Echoes, but Girl can also CONTROL them. That’s how she helped me break into the house.”

: “When we found Girl, she was infected with HUNDREDS of Echoes. Just like Ophelia, in the Ashes.. and here, now. But I don’t understand the CONNECTION, or what gives them this ‘power’.. or CURSE.”

: “But it means she’s VOLATILE, right? If Ophelia stays, she could HURT us. Hurt the kid.”

CasualTalk: Sai, known pillar of mental stability. Also, what the fuck is that sweater you look like fucking Grimace.

CasualTalk: I listened to this once and immediately went “I need to video this because of how bad Sol’s line reads are”. Here’s that video.

CasualTalk: By way of background, Sol is voiced by Glenn Wrage, who has voiceacting and film acting credits going back to 1996 - mostly in bit parts.

CasualTalk: He was in Saving Private Ryan and had minor roles in the original Gothic, Mirror’s Edge, Payday 2, Alien: Isolation, and more recently Elden Ring Nightreign.

CasualTalk: My point is that this is not a Glenn Wrage problem. Ragnar got handed a guy who was built to play bit parts and completely fucked it up. You could have put Nolan North in there and this would be just as bad.

: “What other answer is there?”

: “We look out for our own, like we just fuckin’ did. ‘Curing’ Anomals? Do you even hear yourself? Sounds like you picked up some ideas from your PURITAN friends.”

: “Excuse me?”

: “Curing us is the same as killing us, and you know it. Render us helpless before they put us in CAMPS.”

: “There’s a difference between a practical tool to help Anomals and this.. CONSPIRACY THEORY you’re spinning. You don’t understand what a cure might mean.”

: “Which one of us is gonna get murdered if the PURPLE NAZIS catch us, Theo?”

: “What about what SHE wants? Have you forgotten who this is about? O’s a PERSON.”

CasualTalk: This is the dumbest manufactured controversy. Maybe it’s the fumes from the generator doing their work.

: “Look, we all want her to get HELP, but that doesn’t mean we’re equipped to handle her going NOVA again!”

CasualTalk: Here’s what I want to know. Why was this whole “nova” thing never mentioned anywhere before? I mean, I know why - it’s probably because Ragnar read the Marvel Civil War in the middle of production.

: “The kid’s right. We aren’t worth SHIT if we don’t look out for our OWN.”

: “But only on YOUR terms, apparently.”

: “This is about our SAFETY. We’re risking everyone’s lives just because she and Eli knew each other a MILLION years ago.”

CasualTalk: Also, why is Sai doing anything now? She was a useless character for the entire game up to this point.

CasualTalk: I was going to do a bonus dunk on how I’d fix this game, and the first suggestion I had is start the game with the heist and have Sai and Noam die during it.

CasualTalk: Theo just kind of chimes in because I waited too long. I mean, I wouldn’t want to interrupt or have any kind of control over anything.

CasualTalk: We could do that.. or we could REFLECT.

CasualTalk: This reflection point is only available right now. Maybe someday I’ll 100% achievement this game for charity or something. Call me.

CasualTalk: Oh, and the basement doors have magically fixed themselves.

CasualTalk: Noam is a vote for Wexit (Winehouse Exit).

CasualTalk: Eli is obviously for Amy staying.

CasualTalk: I was not aware Eli was Dominic Torretto now.

CasualTalk: Absolutely none of this is a surprise.

CasualTalk: There’s something wrong with the eyes on Theo’s model, I think it’s that they don’t render right at certain angles, and it makes him look demonic.

: “I’ve let myself get too close to people, let everyone close to ME, I sometimes forget my role on the crew. If I’d kept my distance, stayed more objective, maybe I could’ve seen this coming.”

: “My sister. She’s JUST like Ophelia. Not the SCREAMING, but- she’s in pain. And when she loses control, people get hurt. BADLY.”

CasualTalk: This is something that should’ve been brought up much earlier, but also kind of undermines the entire premise of the game. Ragnar has run into a problem entirely of his own making.

: “At first, it wasn’t too bad. She dislocated my knee one time, but I recovered. Now it’s bad enough that she can’t live with her own CHILDREN. They have to stay with our parents in Monterrey.”

CasualTalk: And so a cure is bad.. why? This feels like Ragnar writing himself into a corner when he could’ve just as easily not done that.

: “So this situation with Ophelia.. it’s PERSONAL. I’m projecting a bit. Jesus, they even LOOK alike… and my sister is the reason I started working for Nova Scotia in the first place. They’re the only ones who can help her.. maybe even CURE her.”

: “That’s why I couldn’t let her go. And I SHOULD have handled it differently. More professionally.”

CasualTalk: Again, this feels like a really stupid argument. This entire chapter so far feels totally unnecessary. Half this GAME feels unnecessary.

CasualTalk: We have to head upstairs now, which.. this house honestly feels really badly designed. Why is the upstairs a hallway with two rooms in it?

CasualTalk: It’s very obviously smaller on the inside than it is on the outside, and in some games I could totally understand that - I wouldn’t want a bunch of pointless rooms in something like a Metroid or a Silent Hill where they’d just get in the way and make navigating a pain in the ass.

CasualTalk: But this is a game with an entire mechanic centered around hunting for collectibles. Why not add a couple of rooms with stuff in them?

CasualTalk: We can try (it’s futile) to dragonshout Sai down but it doesn’t matter. There’s a lot more exposition about to be dumped so I’m going to move things along.

CasualTalk: Is that a Preacher reference? Fuck you, Ragnar, you unoriginal piece of shit!

CasualTalk: Girl wants everyone to play hide and seek. This is completely optional, but there’s an achievement for it so fuck it.

CasualTalk: Doing this magically breaks the basement door again because Eli is hiding down there. I’m going to skip past this because there’s nothing of importance here.

CasualTalk: Except this line, which is really fucking weird when there’s no indication that Theo is gay. We know he was married to a woman and has kids.

CasualTalk: The only person even remotely difficult to find is Sai, who is out of bounds behind some hay bales you have to WMV away.

CasualTalk: For some reason, we get lead outside where Girl is attracting masses of WMVs.

: Is this turning into an even more painful religious fanfic than it already is?

: “Words have ALWAYS had POWER.”

: “But this sounds INSANE, Jacob. Vocals can’t affect REALITY, only people’s PERCEPTION of reality.”

CasualTalk: Hold up! Doesn’t Pax know Sai at this point? How does she explain that? Ragnar, you’re writing holes into your plot that don’t need to be there!

: “Is there a DIFFERENCE? I mean, if enough people believe something.. look, using this.. THING, this..”

CasualTalk: Yes, yes there is. Haven’t you heard of Jonestown?

: “ME-EM.”

: “Right. PERFECT name. Using the ‘meme’, you could, THEORETICALLY, combine fragments of infectious disinformation into powerful, protolanguage-fuelled… well, MEMES.”

CasualTalk: This is PAINFULLY stupid.

: “You’re pretty EXCITED about this, aren’t you?”

: “PAX. You would - Again this is THEORY, but you’d be able to rewrite REALITY. That’s - I mean, WOW. Right? It’s linguistics gone nuclear!”

: “But how would that even work?”

: “I - I don’t – So.. your VOCALS affect PEOPLE. Correct? Anyone who hears your words, including YOU, are affected.”

CasualTalk: Except that’s not true either because Pax can make people believe they’re on fire without making herself believe that.

CasualTalk: Ragnar really fucked himself over with this whole power system.

CasualTalk: If Dustborn was a Shonen Jump manga, it would’ve set a new record for being axed even assuming the WSJ editorial board let it last to seven chapters.

: “And those Vocals alter their PERCEIVED reality.”

: “Hence the whole ROBOT thing.”

: “It doesn’t work on machines, because it’s not FACT, it’s FICTION. No IMAGINATION, no effect. It’s like trying to make a fridge laugh.”

: “But if your VOCALS were AMPLIFIED by the ME-EM, it’d be able to output a massive amount of disinformation.. it’d be like turning on a firehose of memes, across all media, all channels of communication, hitting everyone and every THING.”

: “The effect would no longer be localized. It’d be GLOBAL. Universal. You could change ALL of reality, EVERYONE’s reality. Nothing would be immune. Robots, computers, rabbits, rocks, sunflowers, buildings, governments, climates.. the fucking SUN. You name it.”

: “But this is all theoretical. And potentially INCREDIBLY dangerous. In the wrong hands.. Pax, crafting what amounts to God saying “Let there be LIGHT” could give you the power to make the world a better place…”

: “…Or destroy it altogether. Only one way to find out, right?”

CasualTalk: We now need to walk around and collect WMVs.

CasualTalk: Before we go into this next scene, I’d like you to remember something. You know that whole plot point about Pax hiding her prengancy, and how we’ve never seen her tell anyone about it? Just keep that in mind.

: “Well, that felt.. DIFFERENT. I hope we’re doing the right thing, kid…”

CasualTalk: We go through a couple different cycles of Pax trying to use whatever power she’s gained and failing.

: “GIVE ME CONTROL!”

: “Be CAREFUL, you don’t-”

: “I messed up, I- I thought - I thought I was READY, but I couldn’t -”

: “What are you talking about? Ready for WHAT?”

: “I wasn’t ready. I wasn’t… I think something’s wrong… with the baby.”

: “This is STUPID, but.. may I?”

CasualTalk: Noam isn’t even slightly surprised that Pax is pregnant. Keep in mind that we haven’t seen Pax actually tell anyone.

CasualTalk: Now, we know Noam can sense people for some reason, but if that’s the case why did Noam never once bring it up?

: “Of course, I’m no medical professional, but that.. HUMAN inside you is doing just fine.”

: “Okay. Thank you.”

: “But what about YOU? Are you okay? And did you - did you make me BELIEVE you were.. FLYING? What WAS that? Did you go NOVA?”

: “You can’t tell ANYONE about this. What just happened, and.. the baby. Going NOVA. No one can know.”

: “I’m not talking. But you will.. to me, right? Talk to ME. Don’t handle this alone.”

CasualTalk: WHY DOES EVERY CHARACTER IN THIS FUCKING GAME HAVE A PREGNANCY DETECTOR? SERIOUSLY, WHAT THE FUCK RAGNAR.

CasualTalk: That’s the FOURTH CHARACTER (Betty, CT, Noam, Girl) who has a fucking pregnancy detector.

CasualTalk: Theo and Eli make dinner. We do not care.

: “I just learned that one of you is a SPY and that you’re all criminals but also ‘the good guys’?”

CasualTalk: We’re about to get to the plot twist. But first..

: “Are you FINALLY going to tell us about THE HEIST? What REALLY happened in Purity?”

: “Oh, we REALLY don’t have to.”

: “Go on Sai, the stage is yours! I always pictured it like one of those old video games with blocky edges Ziggy showed me back at the mall.”

CasualTalk: Welcome to THE RAID. It is a turn-based RPG that asks a lot of questions. Questions like “Where did Theo put that gun?” or “Why does Pax have a bat here but then she dropped it before the game started?”

: “We were suddenly SWARMED by those creepy MANDROIDS.”

: “Okay, but there was just ONE by the entrance.”

CasualTalk: The joke is that Sai is an unreliable narrator.

CasualTalk: We can take our turn in any order. Pax has four attacks: Strike is a basic physical attack, Home Run knocks the enemy down, Block does damage and Blocks the two closest enemies, and Push knocks down the two closest enemies.

CasualTalk: In THE RAID, Pax’s shit works on robots for some reason.

CasualTalk: Sai’s gimmick is that she feeds off Pax’s block and knocks enemies down.

CasualTalk: Theo needs enemies to be knocked down to do damage. He also has a single-target Block that amps damage by 50%.

CasualTalk: Noam is a healer.

CasualTalk: The animations are all janky as fuck, and even though it’s on purpose everything looks like shit.

CasualTalk: What I don’t understand is this. You have a semi-working 3D battle mode. Why would you not just use that?

CasualTalk: The Raid is extremely short - it’s only like 10 minutes, and I got the entire thing on video if anyone cares.

CasualTalk: The final fight is against Not-Raiden again. There’s really no point to this - you have Pax block, Sai stomp to knock everything down and then have Theo shoot to take out one enemy a round.

CasualTalk: It never shows how Pax gets shot and just kinda fades to black at the end. I don’t know what I was expecting, but I’m still disappointed.

: “But it makes for GREAT narrative tension!”

: “Dude, I don’t give a SHIT about narrative tension. I care about getting out of this ALIVE.”

: “In case you haven’t noticed, we ARE alive.”

: “But BARELY. With the number of FUCK-UPS we’ve had, someone should’ve bled out by now.”

: “I wouldn’t go THAT far.”

: “That day was the fucking WORST, okay? Did you already forget about Pax getting SHOT? I thought she was going to ACTUALLY die.”

: “To be fair, Pax has almost died a LOT on this road trip.”

: “You wanna joke about Pax dying? She’s, like, the only person on the planet you give a SHIT about.”

: “I’m sure that’s not true.”

: “Whatever mistakes were made, they’re behind us. We’ll be more careful moving forward.”

: “What do you want her to say?”

: “I don’t know, but you can’t tell me that sounds believable coming from the world’s MOST RECKLESS person. You’ve gotten us into more pointless fights than anyone else here.”

: “I’m not saying I haven’t made mistakes, I’m saying we’ve learned from them.”

: “Come on-”

: “DON’T. Don’t. I know you see me as a TOOL at best, and an inconvenience at worst. I’m sick of you trying to TALK me down every time we disagree.”

CasualTalk: HOLY FUCK WE DID IT! SHE’S FUCKING GONE! Actually, we didn’t do anything. Sai does this regardless of what you do.

CasualTalk: This should have been done at the start of the game. Sai should not have even been a fucking character.

: “Is she coming back-”

: “No. No, she’s not coming back.”

CasualTalk: I’m willing to bet one of the other credited writers did this, because there’s no way Ragnar is self-aware enough.

CasualTalk: The party then goes out to search for Sai. Thankfully, we don’t find her.

: “We waited for HOURS. We even went looking for her. What more can we do? She’s an adult, she makes her own decisions. It’s been a HELL of a day. So.. we can talk about it. Some part of it. Any part of it.”

CasualTalk: The rest of this dialog is a plot recap of stuff that just happened in this update, so I’ll ignore it.

CasualTalk: You’ll notice that there are only two red lines on this page.

CasualTalk: Next time, we’ll do.. this, apparently? According to the Steam achievements, 81% of people who have played this game dropped it before finishing Chapter 7.

CasualTalk: Ragnar probably should’ve declared Chapter 7 instead of finishing this game. We’re almost done.