Colors Flying High - Let's Play Persona 5 Royal

You’re not wrong in that a lot of the soundtrack apart from the vocal tracks is kinda forgettable. Hell, I played through Innocent Sin and I have a hard time remembering even a single song from it.

P4’s soundtrack was actually really good if you didn’t mind instrumental tracks. While most people are going to remember the battle music (Reach Out For the Truth/Time To Make History) and the boss themes (I’ll Face Myself, The Almighty, The Genesis) there were also a lot of really good tracks on the side. I think my favorite non-vocal song from that game is the one from later on when Dojima and Nanako are in the hospital and you come home to an empty house. The track is called Alone, and it just… works.

The dungeon themes were also pretty good, Rise’s and Nanako’s in particular.

P5’s OST is pretty good for the most part, except for one thing that I absolutely fucking HATE that Atlus didn’t include.

When you max out an S-Link in P4, it plays this song that I think was also in P3 called “The Path Is Open” over the “you finished an S-Link!” text. It was absolutely the best part of that game and P5 does not have it.

Yeah I mean, it’s not a bad song by any means, but Last Surprise is one of the things everyone remembers about P5.

They did this for P4 Golden as well, except they used Aleister Crowley’s Thoth Tarot instead. I figured when I first played through that that they made the Jester/Hunger/Aeon arcana up. Jester is sort of like the French Fool from what I understand. Hunger is Strength only more about lust than anything, and Aeon is Crowley’s replacement for Judgement.

I’m not saying that people like that don’t exist, but it’s like… I think they just overdid Kamoshida a bit too much. He kind of goes from 0 to 60 the same way Persona 2 went from 0 to 60 right before the Zodiac temples, but then just kind of keeps going. By the end of next update you’ll see how ridiculous it gets. Trust me, I’m not saying this for no reason.

I mean, personality-wise they’re slightly different, but it’s more that they’ve got the same backstory: they’re both track stars who had their legs broken and can’t run again, and as a result become delinquents and drop out of society. The only difference is that Anna doesn’t really give a shit about anything (she’s the only person in the Masked Circle who didn’t ask Joker to grant her wish) and Ryuji does. You could argue that Anna was more tragic in that she had no control over getting hit by a car, but then again Kamoshida was basically going to break Ryuji’s leg one way or the other.

I’d explain more about why they’re alike but that would involve spoiling Eternal Punishment (suffice to say that in EP, Anna is misunderstood in the same way Ryuji is, only to more of an extreme).

1 Like

I know how Kamoshida goes since I have beaten his dungeon at least, and I get where you’re coming from. He definitely starts TOO much, they definitely needed to ramp into the crazy.

Yeah, I kinda figured something like that. I’m excited to see it. Also I feel like Ryuji’s reaction to getting his leg broken is different from Anna’s as well, but that’s a thing we’ll cross when we get to it.

Wait, there are places that actually do that “secret menu” BS? I thought that was just one of those weird anime tropes. I’ve never heard of any places that do that before, and I can’t see any practical benefit from restricting “ordinary” customers from ordering from a portion of your menu. Unless maybe it was supposed to be one of those “open secret” things where it’s supposed to feel like you’re part of an exclusive club, but the wait staff are supposed to find a way to work it into any conversation they have with the customers?

You have this screenshot twice in the update. Not sure if there’s something supposed to be in place of the second instance.

Ryuji.jpeg

They did, kinda. There was a Japan-only mobile phone MMO back in 2009 that sorta went off of P3’s mechanics, apparently.

In this case, by ‘secret’, I mean they had it on the regular menu but dropped it off at one point before they went under. You could still order it, it just wasn’t on the actual menu anymore. I think they had it on the thing over the kitchen as well. The place went under because the guy who owned it apparently was in massive debt for reasons unrelated to the restaurant, which sucks because I want my goddamn meatball burger.

Also, I fixed that double post. It was because I dragged it into the editor in the wrong spot.

My name is Jean Personnage which is French for Juan Persona which is Spanish for John Persona The Phantom Thief Who Shoots People That Ask Him For Help.

I don’t have many social links.

Click Here for Update 5

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Welcome to 04/13/2016. I decided around this point to stop recording the cutscenes in video format because it screws with my ability to take screenshots.

Kawakami: “As you all know, today is the volleyball rally. Head to the gymnasium once you’ve changed. Got it?”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I don’t get how the teachers like him. From experience, when you get people who are total psychopaths like Kamoshida apparently is, you don’t typically see them completely change their personalities like this.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I like how all the people behind Mishima are pallete swaps. It’s not really something you’d notice in motion and it’s a good way to save effort on animation.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Shit, you know what’d rule? If there was an RPG where you get a faceless background character as a party member and it’s revealed that all of the background NPCs are actually one giant army of clones of the same person. Their final attack is having all the clones come together to form something like the final boss of Innocent Sin only it’s a giant boulder made of NPCs.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: And now, Hans Moleman Productions presents… Man Getting Hit By Football.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: If I was any good at editing I would absolutely edit this into the Simpsons clip and keep the “doink” sound effect when the volleyball hits him.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Looking back on it, this just… kinda doesn’t work. It’s hard to tell what’s actually happening - what it’s supposed to be is that Mishima sees the ball but just lets it hit him, I guess. There’s also supposed to be an element of Kamoshida not really giving a shit about it, but they don’t get that across great either.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I honestly think this could’ve been way more effective had he taken Mishima to the nurse and as soon as he gets out of earshot of everyone tells Mishima that he’s a fuck-up or something. Maybe punches him too.

Ryuji: “Get to know each other better, my ass. It’s just a one-man show for him to stroke his ego. And how he acted like he was worried about Mishima? What an abusive d-bag!”

Ryuji: “…Well, anyways. Now’s our chance to go look for the guys we saw were slaves yesterday.”

Ryuji: “Let’s look for the faces we saw at the castle. All the members of the team should be here today. I’ll be sure to find someone to spill about Kamoshida’s physical abuse. Just you wait, asshole.”

Ryuji: “The first one that popped out was a guy from Class D, so let’s start from there. That’s your class.”

Ryuji: “Hopefully, you can get him to talk without any issues. People have been avoidin’ me lately, so… oh, but you’re kinda in the same boat, huh.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Thanks for rubbing it in, Ryuji.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: New to Persona 5 is the ability to fast travel. The class we’re aiming for is 2-D: the first years are on the third floor and the third years are on the ground floor.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Having your head wrapped in bandages looks totally like a normal volleyball injury.

Ryuji: “Hey, that’s the guy who was over at that castle.”

Ryuji: “Kamoshida did it to you, right? Look, I ain’t gonna tell anyone you squealed. Just tell us about how Kamoshida’s abusin’ you.”

Ryuji: “Don’t try n’ hide it! We already know!”

Ryuji: “Well, uh… I…”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Ryuji’s so dense that the possibility of lying and saying that they have something that’s incriminating but not conclusive doesn’t even occur to him.

Ryuji: “…All right, that’s enough. C’mon, let’s go.”

Ryuji: “Crap. If we keep goin’ at this pace, the ball game’s gonna end…”

obs64 2020-08-16 15-00-13-91

Ryuji: “I’ll check the Practice Building for people before clubs start. You handle the Classroom Building. There’s a third yer on the volleyball team that I remember. I think he’s in… 3-C?”

Ryuji: “He was gettin’ beat pretty badly at the castle. He might have some injuries here too…”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: This one took me a second to find because I didn’t immediately realize that the classes are numbered after what year they are, not what floor. They’re numbered based on floor in Persona 1 and Innocent Sin.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: John Persona stares him right in the face. “I am on the road crew. You can tell anything to the road crew. My milk is delicious.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: So yeah, lot of dialog from nameless NPCs in this one. Fortunately, today is MUCH shorter than yesterday. We’re almost done, in fact.

Ann: “It’ll be quick. Anyway, what’s with you? Like, how you were late the other day was a lie and all.”

Ann: “There’s that weird rumor about you too.”

Ann: “Right back at you. You’re not even in our class.”

Ryuji: “…We just happened to get to know each other.”

Ann: “What’re you planning on doing to Mr. Kamoshida?”

Ryuji: “Huh!? … I see. I getcha. You’re buddy-buddy with Kamoshida after all.”

Ann: “This has nothing to do with you, Sakamoto!”

Ryuji: “If you found out what he’s been doin’ behind your back, you’d dump him right away.”

Ann: “What’s that supposed to mean!?”

Ryuji: “You wouldn’t get it.”

Ann: “Anyway, people are already talking about you two. I don’t know what you’re trying to pull, but no one’s gonna help you.”

Ryuji: “Why’s she gotta be so aggressive all the time?”

Ryuji: “We just went to the same middle school. Anyways, that’s not what we’re here to talk about. I had no luck on my end. What about you? Did anything like someone’s name turn up?”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I can’t find a clip of it on Youtube, but this is almost straight out of Shirokuma Cafe. It’s an anime about a polar bear who runs a cafe and does nothing but make bad puns the entire time.

Ryuji: “Huh…? …Special ‘coaching’, huh?”

Ryuji: “True. I always see the guy covered in bruises. Let’s go talk to him before he leaves.”

Mishima: “Sakamoto? And you, too…!?”

Ryuji: “C’mon, we just wanna chat. Kamoshida’s been ‘coaching’ you, huh?” You sure it’s not just physical abuse?"

Ryuji: “What’re you talkin’ all polite for? Anyways… we saw him spike you today. Right in the face.”

Mishima: “That was just because I’m not good at the sport…”

Ryuji: “Still, that doesn’t explain all the other bruises you’ve got.”

Ryuji: “Is he forcin’ you to keep quiet?”

Mishima: “That’s…”

Kamoshida: “What’s going on here?”

Mishima: “I-I’m not feeling well today…”

Kamoshida: “What? Maybe you’re better off quitting then. You’re never going to improve that crappy form unless you show up to practice.”

Kamoshida: “Well, Mishima? Are you coming to practice or not?”

Mishima: “… I’ll go.”

Kamoshida: “As for you, any more trouble and you’ll be gone from this school for sure.”

Ryuji: “Bastard…”

Kamoshida: “Didn’t the principal tell you to keep in line?”

Kamoshida: “Hmph. Just don’t get in the way of my practice. All these unsettling rumors are making the students anxious, after all.”

Ryuji: “That’s your own goddamn fault.”

Kamoshida: “This won’t get us anywhere. Let’s go, Mishima. Shujin Academy is a place where those with aspirations come to learn. Unworthy students like yourselves don’t have any right to be here.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: This? This whole thing could’ve been rolled into that anime cutscene.

Mishima: “…Yes, sir.”

Ryuji: “That asshole… he’s gonna pay for this!”

Mishima: “…There’s no point.”

Ryuji: “Huh!?”

Mishima: “Proving that he’s physically abusing us… is meaningless.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I mean, I get this kind of thing happens in real life (even though most of that happened after Persona 5 was made) but they treat Kamoshida like he’s yakuza or something.

Ryuji: “This has gotta be a joke…”

Mishima: “Don’t be a pain. You don’t understand what I’m going through. Shouldn’t you of all people know that nothing’s going to help!?”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Unfortunately, we get marched right upstairs so I can’t look at the TV. What I did do though, since I think this is the first night we can do it…

9_2iVBrO_400x400: The Band-Aces aren’t much: they’re a revival item that leaves the character at 50% HP. The real treasure here is the three Hogyoku Apples, which are a full heal for the entire party.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: We also get 50,000 yen. This will help IMMENSELY early on when we’ll need to spend a bunch of money on boosting social stats.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I’m going to put the 14th in this update because the 15th and 16th are both long cutscene days from what I remember.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Nah, that’s Sevens and only if you go in the clock tower. Have you heard the one about how Clair de Lune sells a Legendary Gun, but you have to order something disgusting to eat it?

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Shiho certainly looks more beaten up than the last time we saw her.

Ann: “That bruise above your eye… is that from practice, too?”

Shiho: “Y-Yeah…”

Ann: “Are you sure you’re not pushing yourself too hard?”

Shiho: “Shouldn’t you take that?”

Ann: “It’s probably just my part-time job… I think.”

Shiho: “I… should get going.”

Ann: “Shiho… are you sure you’re doing okay?”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Yep, she looks fine. Nothing wrong there.

Ann: “Today won’t work… I’m… I’m not feeling so good. Sorry… bye.”

Shiho: “…What? Oh… I’m in the way, aren’t I? Sorry…”

Shiho: “Huh…? Um, well… Hm, you don’t look familiar. Could you be that transfer student from Class D?”

Shiho: “Um, this might not be any of my business, but don’t let the rumors get to you, okay?”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: They do not bother me. My name is Juan Persona. I work on the road crew. I do important work on the road crew.

Shiho: “I’m glad to hear that. My best friend is often misunderstood too, all because of her looks…”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Your best friend is Lisa Silverman!? I mean, she kinda is.

Shiho: Ah, sorry. I didn’t mean to drag on like that. Anyway, I have to go practice. I’ll see you around."

Ryuji: “Is that what it looks like?”

Ryuji: “Kamoshida had to have told 'em something! At this rate… looks like we’ll have to go to him directly.”

Ryuji: “I know… but seriously, isn’t there something we can do? Can you think of anything?”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: So here’s the thing. The game never really gives a valid reason as to why this shouldn’t work, and I think this is part of why Kamoshida isn’t a great villain. In a setting like Persona 4’s I could see something like Kamoshida being golf buddies with the chief of police, which shields him from any abuse inquiries. I dunno, I just feel like when your villain can be defeated by a really simple and obvious question they’re just not well-written.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Once we get through the first two options, the third one that we need to do to progress opens.

Ryuji: “The king…? You mean that other world’s Kamoshida?”

Ryuji: “I didn’t think of that, but… is there any meaning to -”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Oh look, it’s Morgana. Outside of the dark world, he’s a cat.

Ryuji: “That voice… is that you, Morgana!?”

Morgana: “How dare you, up and leaving me the other day!”

Ryuji: “The cat’s talkin’!?”

Morgana: “I am NOT a cat! This is just what happened when I came to this world! It was a lot of trouble finding you two.”

Ryuji: “Wait… you came to our world!? Does that mean you’ve got a phone!?”

Morgana: “You don’t need one when you’re at my level. I did get pretty lost making my escape though…”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I feel like the only time the phrase ‘you don’t need one when you’re at my level’ should be used is in DBZ.

Ryuji: “That aside, why can you talk!? You’re a cat!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: God I wish this was Persona 2 so that Morgana’s origin story could be that someone spread a rumor that Garfield is real and thus Morgana was born, not realizing that Garfield doesn’t actually talk in the comics… or does he?

Morgana: “How should I know!?”

Ryuji: “You hearin’ this too?”

Morgana: “You guys are having a rough time of this, hm? I heard you mention something about witnesses.”

Ryuji: “Oh, shuddup.”

Morgana: “You know, I could tell you a thing or two about what to do about Kamoshida. You were pretty close just a moment ago.”

Ryuji: “God, that condescendin’ attitude! This thing’s gotta be Morgana!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Morgana still uses the cartoon cat portraits even when he’s a normal cat, by the way.

Ryuji: “Ack! Quiet down!”

Ryuji: “Meow? Does that mean only us two can understand what you’re sayin’?”

Morgana: “Looks like it.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I really, really need some fanart of Jon Arbuckle as Joker and he’s cursed to be the only one who can understand Garfield. It’d be like a Stephen King novel.

Ryuji: “What the hell’s goin’ on? Anyways, what you were talkin’ about earlier… is it for real?”

Morgana: “You’re quite the skeptic for being an idiot.”

Ryuji: “Hey, tell us more. Then again, this probably ain’t the best place…”

Ryuji: “Enough of that! You said you know how we can do something about Kamoshida, right?”

Morgana: “It has to do with what this guy was talking about earlier. You’ll need to attack his castle.”

Ryuji: “What do you mean?”

Morgana: “That castle is how Kamoshida sees this school. He doesn’t realize what happens in there, but it’s deeply connected to the depths of his heart.”

Morgana: “Thus, if the castle disappears, it would naturally impact the real Kamoshida.”

Ryuji: “What’d happen?”

Morgana: “A Palace is a manifestation of a person’s distorted desires. So, if that castle were no more…”

Morgana: “Precisely! You sure pick things up fast!”

Ryuji: “But… is that really gettin’ back at him?”

Ryuji: “You for real? That’s possible!?”

Morgana: “And since the Palace will no longer exist, he’ll forget about what we did there as well. Not only will we be able to bring Kamoshida down, but there won’t even be a trace of our involvement.”

Ryuji: “That’s amazing! You are one incredible cat!”

Morgana: “True, except for the cat part!”

Ryuji: “So? How do we get rid of the Palace!?”

Morgana: “By stealing the Treasure held within.”

Ryuji: “Stealing…?”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: The concept of stealing has never occurred to Ryuji.

Morgana: “I’ll tell you more once you agree to go ahead with this. It’s my most valuable, secret plan after all. If you want to help me out, I’ll gladly teach you. What’s your call?”

Ryuji: “Our luck’s runnin’ dry lookin’ for witnesses. Guess we have no choice but to go along…”

Morgana: “…Good. Oh right, there’s one more thing I should tell you.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: We’ve actually seen this before. This is a direct call-back to Innocent Sin, where during Caracol it’s possible to have Yukino’s shadow kill herself if you fuck up a dialog option.

https://www.lp.zone/uploads/default/optimized/3X/2/b/2b1da63a3a6074d83c89d7708abedf67f1861178_2_690x436.png

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Even though the real Yukino is outside the dungeon at this point, when we met up with her again on the non-canon run of Caracol in the Innocent Sin LP…

https://www.lp.zone/uploads/default/optimized/3X/1/3/13b44e29b4401da6ed4bab64069e361cd2bb0e63_2_690x436.jpeg

https://www.lp.zone/uploads/default/optimized/3X/e/2/e2ac181f65359b3453705215af0aacaf8e0747ff_2_690x436.png

image

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Basically, if your shadow dies, you go braindead. Of course, on the canon run, Yukino survived.

Morgana: “So…”

Ryuji: “They might die!?”

Morgana: “Will you listen to everything I have to say first?”

Ryuji: “Would their death be our fault?”

Morgana: “Aren’t you determined enough to face those kinds of risks?”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I mean, Kamoshida’s not really anyone we care about so there’s really no reason not to kill his shadow.

Ryuji: “Hey… what do you think?”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: By “interested” I mean “interested in putting a bullet in Kamoshida’s shadow.”

Ryuji: “For real!?”

Morgana: “Sheesh… I come all this way, and this is what I get. It’s not like anyone will ever find out.”

Ryuji: “That’s not the point!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I feel like the whole “No, don’t do it, if you do it you’ll be just as bad as him!” thing is a bad cliche by this point. I get that Ryuji is a dumbass but still.

Morgana: “Isn’t this your only option? I’ll come back later. Make sure you’ve made your decision by then.”

Ryuji: “I’ll try and see if I can figure out another way. C’mon, let’s get outta here.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: We make it no further than the school gates before Ryuji decides to text. Seriously, he’s like a clingy boyfriend.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: For the record, all the conversations on the way back are basically “I wonder if Ann is having an inappropriate relationship with Kamoshida.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: On the way back, at Shibuya Station, we run into Ann on her phone.

Ann: “Wait, what!? That’s not what you promised! And you call yourself a teacher!?”

Ann: “This has nothing to do with Shiho!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I thought it would be amusing to be John Persona for a bit while we still have the ability to pick our dialog options freely.

Ann: “Haven’t you heard of privacy?”

Ann: “…No, I was out of line. Sorry. So how much did you hear?”

Ann: “Shiho…”

Ann: “It’s nothing at all… nothing…”

obs64 2020-08-20 20-48-53-15

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Ann then runs away because her night job as Lisa Silverman is coming up and she can’t let anyone know they’re the same person.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: We find her in the underground mall, just across from the juice stand.

Ann: “Why…? Why do you keep worrying about me?”

Ann: “It was just an argument.”

obs64 2020-08-20 20-50-37-12

9_2iVBrO_400x400: John Persona just kind of stares awkwardly.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: “Huh? Oh, sorry, I was on another plane of existence.”

Ann: “I wasn’t asking for a serious response… but I do feel a bit better now. I’m gonna head home.”

Ann: “I’ll try and think of a way to persuade Kamoshida. Well… thanks.”

Mishima: “Are you leaving?”

Shiho: “What is it?”

Mishima: “Mr. Kamoshida’s asking for you. He’s in the PE Faculty Office.”

Shiho: “What did he say?”

Mishima: “…I don’t know. Well… I have to go.”

Sojiro: “Don’t gimme those lies. By the way, you haven’t been hanging around any bad influences, have you?”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: John Persona, hang out with bad influences? Never. John Persona isn’t even capable of hanging out.

Sojiro: “…All right. Even if you do hang with people, just be careful you don’t choose someone who’ll ruin your life.”

Sojiro: “Look at the time. Seriously, think about how I feel having to stay up here waiting for you.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: We’re then forced into the bedroom, which we cannot leave. This is something I forgot to mention - in the base game at least, if you go into the bedroom at night you’re stuck there.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: And that’s it for this update. Next time, another long day with a fuckload of cutscenes, most of them unnecessary.

1 Like

Separate post because it’s one of those date-limited things, but the first P5D stream will likely happen after we reach 04/20. 04/15 and 04/16 will probably be separate updates because they’re both long cutscenes, and the 17th, 18th, and 19th will likely be a single update because they’re all short days. 4/20 will also be an incredibly long day.

I can’t say how long it’ll take me to actually reach 4/20, but if anyone wants to co-commentate on the P5D stream, let me know.

1 Like

On the one hand, you might could ask if John Persona, A Talking Cat?, and Historically Dubious Rebel using their protected status at the only ones who can go into the mind palace and render Kamoshida a vegetable without fear of identification or retaliation could resemble Kamoshida using his protected status to do whatever he wants to students, and wonder what darkness could be at the end of the road Our Heroes are on.

On the other hand this is an Evil High School and the only staff we’ve seen are Coach Abuse, Ms. I Can’t Do Anything, and Principal Kingpin so I’m probably overthinking this.

It’s either that or I’m turning that talk in the cafe into a “John Persona what the fuck are you talking about?” meme.

1 Like

I mean, I don’t think those things are comparable at all even if you removed the overtly evil staff that allows it to happen.

I don’t think it’s overthinking by the way. I think even when a game is… faulty, in ways, you can still get something from it by analyzing it. For all the flaws Persona 5 probably has, it is a legitimate question to ask on “are we any different from the bad guys, because we ARE basically mind fucking people into being good which is kinda nasty”.

And there’s something to be gained from the realization that no, not at all. You’re nothing alike and what the Phantom Thieves are doing is, while super fucked up, also the right choice in the situation from a moral standpoint.

1 Like

I am disappointed Reality!Morgana didn’t get normal cat portraits. Why did they even make Royal if they weren’t going to fix the most glaring mistake? (… that a department outside of writing could handle.)

I can appreciate Ryuji’s desire to not murder someone. He’s a high school student who wants to do the right thing, but it turns out being able to infiltrate people’s psyche isn’t as easy an out as he wants it to be. For now. But from an outside perspective, yes. Please dunk Kamoshida in the trash ASAP.

1 Like

Part of my problem is that could have worked if Kamoshida wasn’t so over the top. If the question was something more like “Is what this guy did really bad enough to warrant mind controlling and/or killing him” and there was at least some ambiguity it could work.

It’s because art costs money and Royal was a cash-in.

Principal Kingpin really is the best way to describe him, and now I have to wonder if Hashino watched Netflix Daredevil (which was an okay show but the acting was… very on and off) and was like “Shit, I gotta have that.”

1 Like

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Just as a heads up, this update contains off-screen sexual assault, attempted sexual assault and a suicide attempt. In other words, it’s the same kinda meh writing we’ve seen up to this point. If you find any of those things disturbing, I’ll just sum up this entire update in two sentences: Shiho attempts suicide and Ann is captured by Shadow Kamoshida before Joker and Ryuji save her and she awakens into the heroine from Shin Megami Tensei 1 in a catsuit. There’s a fuckload of tutorials and a tutorial bossfight. and let you skip the entire thing. Come back on 4/16.

Summary

9_2iVBrO_400x400: It’s 4/15, and time for another day full of tutorials I really don’t need because I’ve played the first two games.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: There are three branches of government. One always tells the truth, one always lies, and the third has already evacuated the nation’s GDP into their offshore bank accounts. Using one question, how can you solve for X?

Ushimaru: “The National Diet is legislative, the Cabinet is executive, and the Supreme Court is judiciary.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: As opposed to the National Diet in America, which is more along the lines of carnivore vs. vegan.

Ushimaru: “This division of power provides checks and balances, which ensures no one branch becomes unstoppable.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Shinzo Abe banging on the front door of a bar at 3AM: “You can’t lock me out! I’m unstoppable!” The LDP was a mistake. (Edit: Abe announced his resignation while I was editing this, so I guess he’s not unstoppable anymore. The LDP was still a mistake.)

9_2iVBrO_400x400: One thing I will give this game credit for: watch how in the next few cutscenes, they manage to hide Morgana somewhere. I never noticed this the first time I played it, because I’m nearsighted and my couch was way too far back from the TV. I feel like everyone who worked on this game did an amazing job and then Hashino just fucked up.

Morgana: “No matter how much thinking you do, there’s only one option. You’d be better off just listening to me.”

Ushimaru: “Hm? Did I just hear a cat just now?”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Who said that? Which one of ya’ll dead motherfuckers just said that shit? Was it you, string bean? You skinny-ass lookin’ motherfucker? Turn around and say it again!

9_2iVBrO_400x400: No, I didn’t mistype that, by the way. He actually says “Did I just hear a cat just now”.

Ushimaru: “Hmm… could that rumored cat be somewhere nearby? Settle down! We’re in the middle of an important lecture!”

Morgana: “If only he knew I’m reading this too…”

Ushimaru: “Enough! This is a classroom!”

Ushimaru: “Hey! Stay in your seats! Do not step foot outside of this room!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: The first time I saw this scene, I was immediately reminded of a similar scene from Great Teacher Onizuka. On a side note, I had not seen the anime for that since around 2005 and hoo boy does it look dated. They made a reboot called Paradise Lost which I read like half of then stopped.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Ann is, of course, staring because Shiho just did a perfect swan dive into a flip before busting through the moonroof of the principal’s Cresta and driving off into the sunset. Unfortunately, because the Cresta was a 1998 model with like 350,000 miles on it, she doesn’t get far.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Also, Ushimaru is an airplane now. I’m now imagining him going “Fuck this shit, I worked for Honda for 35 years and now I’m a goddamn Cessna!” and then making engine noises with his mouth, jumping out the window, and flying off like an airplane with his arms outstretched, his hands flapping like ailerons. Years later, an isekai anime is made based on his life story, in which the protagonist is hit by a runaway helicopter and reincarnates as a Cessna.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: On our way into the practice building, we come across the worst girl in this game. Her name is Makoto, and a lot of people accuse her of being Marie 2.0 and ruining the plot.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: If anyone found out that Ushimaru became an airplane, they’d realize there’s nothing stopping them from becoming airplanes as well and then this turns into a Junji Ito story.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: She’s the student council president, by the way. Because of course she is. Clearly this is a deconstruction about how the Class Rep type is usually the best girl, but she’s actually the worst.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I like to think that the two un-named teachers are actually only an inch tall and that’s why the camera is at this perspective.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: We’re about to enter the Hashino Zone, where the plot will temporarily stop making sense.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I’d also like you to note that Shiho is very much still alive and also still awake.

Ann: “…Huh? …Kamoshida!?”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: The way he says “volleyball team” for no reason kind of makes me remember the magic words from Stone Ocean. Stone Ocean was dumb.

Ryuji: “That guy… hey, wasn’t Mishima acting weird?”

Ryuji: “…We’re gonna make him talk this time.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Can you spot Morgana? He’s behind Ryuji on top of the locker.

Ryuji: “Why’d you run like that? Huh!?”

Mishima: “I didn’t run…”

Ryuji: “She jumped and tried to kill herself!”

Mishima: “L-leave me alone…”

Ryuji: “He’s right! We ain’t tryin’ to get you busted. We won’t say you talked either!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: What is it with this game and the passive voice? Seriously.

Ryuji: “Wait, what!?”

Mishima: “I was called by him a number of times too… to the teacher’s room. It wasn’t just me or Suzui either. He’d nominate someone when he was in a bad mood… and hit them.”

Ryuji: “So the physical punishment thing was for real…”

Mishima: “But yesterday, he called Suzui out of the blue. She didn’t make any mistakes or anything…”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: So yeah, in addition to random beatings, breaking Ryuji’s leg, driving Shiho to suicide and leaking Joker’s information, Kamoshida also forced himself on Shiho.

Ryuji: “He didn’t…! That son of a bitch!”

Ryuji: “You bastard! The hell did you do to that girl!?”

Kamoshida: “What are you talking about?”

https://wiki.teamfortress.com/w/images/thumb/a/ab/07_comic_large.jpg/800px-07_comic_large.jpg

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Okay, Ryuji. You’ve got the chair kicking part down, now all you have to do is piss in a bottle and throw it at Kamoshida. He’ll never see it coming, then you punch him for mini-crits.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: The best part is that someone actually ripped Ryuji’s model into GMod so you can in fact have Ryuji throwing Jarate. Unfortunately, no one has ripped Kamoshida’s model.

Mishima: “What you did… wasn’t coaching!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: By the way, spotted Morgana yet? He’s kind of obscured by the portraits.

Kamoshida: “What did you say?”

Mishima: “You… you ordered me to call Suzui here… I can only imagine what you did to her…!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I don’t know who voices Mishima in English or what he sounds like, but I imagine him sounding like Huey in The Phantom Pain.

Kamoshida: “You’re going on and on about things you have no proof of… basically, you’re making these claims because you can’t be a regular on the team, right?”

Mishima: “That’s not what this is about…!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Man, that’s the fastest coma diagnosis I’ve ever seen. Keep in mind this is maybe five minutes from when we saw Shiho on the stretcher… when she was still awake and talking. I’m pretty sure comas don’t work that way.

Mishima: “No… that can’t be…”

I like how all three of them have cell phones but not one of them thought to video this.

Ryuji: “You goddamn…”

Kamoshida: “This again? Does this mean we need to have yet another case of ‘self-defense’?”

Ryuji: “But still!”

Kamoshida: “Oh? You’re stopping him? What a surprise. There’s no need to hold back. Why not attack me?”

Kamoshida: “…Ohhh, you caaaan’t. Hahaha, but of course you can’t!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: And here’s our arbitrary deadline. How this makes sense, I don’t know.

Ryuji: “Wha-”

Mishima: “You can’t make a decision like that…!”

Kamoshida: “Who would seriously consider what scum like you say? You threatened me too, Mishima, so you’re just as responsible.”

Mishima: “Huh?”

Kamoshida: “To think you didn’t know why I kept someone as talentless as you on the team. You act like a victim, but you leaked his criminal records, didn’t you?”

Kamoshida: “It’s all over the internet, correct? How terrible.”

Ryuji: “Mishima…?”

Mishima: “He told me to do it. I had no choice…”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I can only read his dialog in Huey’s voice now.

Kamoshida: “Now, are we finished here? You’re all expelled!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Kamoshida has a very busy schedule. As soon as he’s out of here, he has to go kick a box of puppies. Not the box itself, but removing each individual puppy and kicking it. Then he has to go steal a runabout.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: This is why doing the whole “Personas don’t work in the real world anymore” thing was dumb. Seriously, just imagine him being all “Hahaha I can get away with anything” and then Joker lights him on fire like Tatsuya did with Principal Hanya.

Ryuji: “I can’t believe this asshole’s gettin’ away with this!”

Ryuji: “Huh…? Oh right, we have that!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I’m going to spoil something from the very beginning of Eternal Punishment, because this entire first segment of the game is kind of a call-back to it. In Eternal Punishment, Joker is a magic hitman/serial killer who takes kill targets through the Joker Game, where people call their own cell numbers and say a name. His first target that’s shown in EP is Principal Hanya, so technically we made the canon choice in Innocent Sin.

Kamoshida: “Huh? Have you lost your minds? You worthless kids aren’t making any sense, but sure, go ahead and try. After all, you’ll have plenty of time to kill until expulsion…”

Ryuji: “We gotta hurry up and go to that world and beat the shit outta that asshole!”

Morgana: “We’re not beating him up. We’re simply stealing his distorted desires.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I mean, we’re only going into his brain to steal his Ann-shaped sex doll. Honestly, that’s kind of the lamest thing you could do with a magic castle where random shit you think comes to life. I’d be re-enacting my unwritten Death Note fanfic where a frustrated interior designer gets their hands on the Death Note and writes down “Open Concept Interiors” and the cause of death as “Devoured by weasels”.

Morgana: “Can I assume that you’ve made up your minds about this - about how he might suffer a mental shutdown?”

Ryuji: “…I have. Someone almost died because of him! I don’t give a rat’s ass what happens to him anymore!”

Morgana: “And you?”

Morgana: “…Then it’s settled.”

Ryuji: “By the way, is gettin’ rid of a Palace hard? You’ve tried it before, right?”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: And that’s how Morgana got banned from every Denny’s in a ten-mile radius.

Morgana: “…When did I ever say that?”

Ryuji: “…Eh? WHAT!? Were you just pretendin’ to know!?”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I wonder if Kamoshida is an evil version of the Devil Summoner protagonist or something with how quickly he spreads rumors.

Ryuji: “So you came all the way to tell us that?”

Ann: “If you’re going to deal with Kamoshida… let me in on it too.”

Ann: “I can’t just sit back and do nothing after what happened to Shiho!”

Ryuji: “This has nothing to do with you… don’t butt your head into this.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I feel like if this was Satomi Tadashi still writing this, there’s a good chance the missing word would be “girlfriend.”

Morgana: “…That was harsh.”

Ryuji: “We can’t take her somewhere like that.”

Morgana: “I hope she doesn’t do anything too crazy. Women can be much bolder than men at times.”

Ryuji: “We just gotta hurry up and deal with Kamoshida. Let’s go already!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I kind of hate the whole Phantom Thieves thing. It sounds like something a ten year old would come up with.

Ryuji: “Huh? Phantom thieves?”

Morgana: “Those who covertly sneak in and stylishly steal Treasure - that is what we become!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I think Morgana has the term “thief” confused with “male model” but whatever.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: “It sounds cool” says local caveman Ryuji Sakamoto, while trying to figure out how fire works.

Ryuji: “So we just gotta say the school, Kamoshida’s name, and… “castle”? Then we end up in bizarro world.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Oh, speaking of the school’s name. I read a manga recently (it was bad) that claimed that the word “Shujin” is Japanese for “Master” but can also be used for “Husband”. “Master Academy” certainly sounds like the kind of place someone like Kamoshida would teach. If this was Satomi Tadashi there’s a good chance they’d go for the double meaningful kanji and have Joker be gay (“Yeah, I met my husband at good ol’ Husband High.”)

Ryuji: “…How the hell’s all this work? Someone make it?”

Ryuji: “That’s kinda creepy, but eh, seems useful enough. We’ll show that effin’ Kamoshida!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Ryuji is about 50 years too young to be quoting The Doors.

Ann: “What is this!?”

Ryuji: “T-Takamaki!?”

Ann: “That voice… Sakamoto!? And… are you Kurusu-kun?”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Nah, he’s John Persona.

Ryuji: “Wh-wh-why are you here!?”

Ann: “How should I know!? What’s going on? Hey, where are we!? Isn’t this the school!?”

Morgana: “I see. Perhaps she was dragged in because of that app thing. If multiple people can enter with the person who uses it, it stands to reason it’ll pull in anyone nearby.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: So okay, why can’t we just pull what they did in Persona 4 and throw Kamoshida into his own palace? P4 already established that your shadow wants nothing more than to kill you, all you’d have to do is toss him in and he’s dead.

Ryuji: “For real?”

Ann: “Wait, so THIS is related to Kamoshida!?”

Morgana: “The Shadows are going to find us if you make a scene.”

Ann: “No way! It talked! Oh my god, it’s a monster cat!”

Morgana: “Monster…?”

Ann: “You better explain what’s going on! I won’t leave until you do!”

Ryuji: “Looks like we gotta force her. But… how’re we supposed to do that?”

Morgana: “Just take her back to where we came in. That’s how it worked last time, right?”

Ryuji: “O-oh, yeah. Can you lend me a hand?”

Ryuji: “We can’t deal with Kamoshida if we don’t!”

Ann: “What’re you-”

Ryuji: “We’ll explain after everything’s over!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Naturally, they had to do it this way because Hashino.

Ryuji: “Whoa, s-sorry, I-I didn’t mean-”

Ryuji: “…That’s not important!”

Ann: “You guys seriously - ah!?”

Morgana: “You should’ve checked the tools you used! Why do I - the one who was just watching - know more about it than you two!?”

Ryuji: “Sh-shuddup!”

Ryuji: “Ah geez, Takamaki found out right when we were startin’ off… we gotta deal with this fast!”

Morgana: “That girl’s name is Ann Takamaki, right? Lady Ann…”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Seriously, Morgana has no taste in women.

Morgana: “We’re counting on you, Joker!”

Ryuji: “Joker? That a nickname?”

Morgana: “Don’t refer to it in such a lame way. It’s a codename. What kind of stupid phantom thief would use their real name!? I’m not down for that!”

Morgana: “And there’s no telling what kind of effect yelling our real names will have on the Palace. It’s just a precaution.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Cool, my codename will be Iron Cock. I am so glad I didn’t use that video in Innocent Sin so I could use it here. I almost did during the bomb arc.

Ryuji: “So, uh, why’s he Joker?”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Well obviously because it’s a reference to the two Jokers in Persona 2.

Morgana: “Next up is you, Ryuji. You’ll be… let’s see… ‘Thug’.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Thug makes me think of Tony Hawk’s Underground and how it’d actually be a big-brain move to make your codename Tony Hawk because no one would believe you exist.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Now we just need a Bulk and we’ve got Power Rangers.

Skull: “Oooh! That sounds awesome! I’m Skull! What do we do about this one’s code name?”

Morgana: “Well, if Joker thinks it’s easier to call me that, then I’ll go with it. All right. From here on out, we’re Joker, Skull, and Mona.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: The next bit of this is tutorials, which I’ll be skipping over for the most part.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Holding R2 allows you to dash, indicated by the motion lines on the sides of the screen. This is mostly for moving through areas you’ve cleared of enemies, since running acts like a magnet for encounters.

Kamoshadow: “However, I can’t allow that trash to ransack my castle! Strengthen the security! Kill them on sight! I’ll reward whoever brings me their heads.”

Skull: “Hey, Mona. Can’t we just beat the crap outta him and call it a day?”

Morgana: “Look at those soldiers, idiot! It’d be suicide. And I’m sure you don’t want a repeat of last time.”

Morgana: “Besides, don’t you want him to confess his sins? There’s no point to beating him up. We need to steal his materalized desires… the Treasure.”

Skull: “Fiiiine. So where is it?”

Morgana: “It has to be somewhere in the depths of this castle. Let’s infiltrate further while he’s out here!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: We then get a tutorial on demon negotiation, which I’m sure all of you got enough of in the earlier games. Just like P1 and P2, we can ask for money or items: but there’s not much of a point to doing this. We don’t have the ability to ask them to join us because this is a tutorial.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: More awkward localization.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: By the way, notice how Ryuji is holding that shotgun. That is not how you hold a shotgun. Even on a low-recoil shotgun like the AA12, that’s just asking to have your wrist injured.

SaturnJoker: This is how we get new Personas, in addition to fusing the ones we find in battle. We actually get to keep this Pixie, which will be useful because before we leave Kamoshida’s dungeon for real, we’re going to need four different arcana of Persona: Chariot, Lovers, Death, and I think Hierophant.

SaturnJoker: One nice thing P5 does is that it keeps track of weaknesses that you’ve already seen. In this case, we know that Bicorn is weak to lightning.

SaturnJoker: The game will even give you a special cut-in if you hit a weakness.

SaturnJoker: Normally I’d be way stingier with SP, but in this case we don’t have much further to go and it’s basically a free Persona.

NEW PERSONA: Bicorn

Origin: Unknown, possibly England

First Appearance: Shin Megami Tensei II

Evil unicorn associated with adultery.

image

SaturnJoker: Bicorn is kinda garbage, but we’ll be keeping him around as fusion fodder. He’s also useful as a cheap compendium grab later on when we do the Hermit confidant.

SaturnJoker: Hear that? That’s the sound of Jung being thrown out a window.

SaturnJoker: We continue down the hallway and find a door.

SaturnJoker: There’s three battles in this room, and I only managed to ambush the first one. I could actually have gotten Pyro Jack as a Persona… except I forgot that they’re weak to wind and not just ice.

SaturnJoker: Unfortunately, what happened was that as soon as I killed the first encounter, the second and third ones spotted me. One Bicorn isn’t too bad - guns take it down quick.

SaturnJoker: Except I forgot that in P5, encounters can “chain” if you get spotted.

SaturnJoker: Thankfully, Ryuji had just enough ammo left to knock them all down.

SaturnJoker: At the end of the room is a chest with a weapon I only equip because the game lets you do it automatically via a dialog prompt. Seriously, with the buffs that guns got, we have almost no reason to ever use physical attacks.

Morgana: “A safe room. We can discuss our strategy inside. There are a lot of places even I don’t know about in here…”

Ann: “I just said the words Sakamoto said, and I ended up-”

Ann: “Huh?”

Skull: “Just gettin’ this far’s been a real pain in my ass!”

Morgana: “It’s all because you guys provoked Kamoshida, you know. Still… he seems to be awfully on guard…”

Skull: “Anyways, how’re we supposed to steal that Treasure thing?”

Morgana: “Don’t be so hasty. First, we’ll need to secure an infiltration route.”

Skull: “A what?”

Morgana: “A path to the treasure’s location.”

SaturnJoker: I’m no expert, but I have a feeling those last couple of lines were something they needed in Japanese because there’s no word for “infiltration route” and it uses katakana.

Morgana: “But honestly, I think we’ll need a little more manpower in order to accomplish this. At the very least, one more person would be nice…”

Skull: “Hey, you say you don’t have your memories and all, but somehow you still know about that kinda stuff? Do you think this thing’s really got amnesia?”

SaturnJoker: I believe in Morgana if only because he’s so annoying that he’s unlikely to turn evil and get killed off.

Morgana: “At least you’re a step above that moron.”

Skull: “Don’t call me a moron! You sure talk big, but what if it turns out you’re just some stray cat in the end?”

Morgana: “That can’t be…”

Skull: “Princess…?”

Skull: “Who’s this princess they’re talkin’ about?”

Morgana: “I should probably look into this!”

Skull: “Stuff like the castle and that navigation app are mysterious… but Morgana’s got 'em both beat.”

Skull: “Crap, sorry! What was I again? Oh yeah - Skull!”

Skull: “That was fast!”

Morgana: “Your friend… Lady Ann!”

SaturnJoker: What is this, Kingdom Hearts?

Skull: “Wait, what? We sent her home earlier.”

Morgana: “If Lady Ann does indeed have the app, it could be possible.”

Skull: “Oh no… don’t tell me it got put on hers just like mine!? Dammit! We let her out for her own safety, and she just came back in by herself!”

Morgana: “We need to hurry and rescue her!”

SaturnJoker: I don’t know why, but Morgana saying that reminds me of Half-Life: Full Life Consequences. John Persona who was Ann Persona’s brother was one day sitting in an office, typing at a computer.

Skull: “She totally doesn’t get what’s goin’ on!”

Morgana: “Let’s hurry! We have to save her!”

SaturnJoker: It’s a nice touch that if you look, one of the armors is uh… melting. By the way, see how Joker is at half health? I was too stingy to heal him and forgot that Morgana has Dia.

Kamoshadow: “So, this is the intruder.”

Ann: “More importantly, what is this place? Why’s the school turned into something like this?”

Kamoshadow: “I can’t believe you mistook my Ann for someone like her.”

Kamoshadow: “Are you afraid?”

Ann: “What is that outfit? Have you lost your mind?”

Kamoshadow: “I do as I please here. After all, this is my castle… the world of my desires.”

Ann: “What the–!? Wait… is this some red-light district?”

SaturnJoker: I just realized something. No one has done fanart of Groverhaus as a Palace and I feel like that’s a mistake. Grover walking around with a giant building inspector badge approving the load-bearing drywall. Seriously though, “This is my castle, the world of my desires” sounds like something Shadow Grover would say as he approves another mismatched window placed at the exact height for a child to fall out of it.

Kamoshadow: “What a lively slave.”

Ann: “This isn’t funny! Enough of the bullshit, Kamoshida!”

Kamoshadow: “The girl’s decided to tell me off. What do you think of that?”

SaturnJoker: Naturally, Fake Ann talks like a valley girl.

Kamoshadow: “In that case… she should be executed. Now then, how should I play with you? Shall I tear you into little pieces?”

Ann: “Are you kidding me?”

SaturnJoker: Why does Kamoshida have an entire harem of Chie?

Skull: “Is that what he thinks of the girls on the volleyball team!?”

Morgana: “Hey, that’s-!”

Kamoshadow: “Just when I was about to start enjoying myself…”

Ann: “What’s the deal with this guy!?”

Skull: “You little…”

Kamoshadow: “How many times are you gonna come back? I bet you’re just like those thieves. You came because you’re pissed at me, huh?”

Kamoshadow: “But, ah… I forget that chick’s name, but it’s your fault she jumped, you know.”

Ann: “Huh?”

Kamoshadow: “You were so reluctant to throw yourself onto me that I had her take your place.”

Ann: “You bastard!”

Skull: “No!”

Skull: “Dammit!”

Kamoshadow: “Just sit back and enjoy the dismantlement show.”

Skull: “H-Hey, what’re we gonna do!? Takamaki!”

Ann: “Is this… my punishment for what happened to Shiho?”

Kamoshadow: “That’s more like it. You should’ve looked like this from the start.”

Ann: “Shiho… I’m so sorry…”

Ann: “Huh…? No… I don’t want that. You’re right.”

Ann: “Letting this piece of shit toy with me… what was I thinking!?”

Kamoshadow: “It’s like I always say. Slaves should just behave and-”

Ann: “…Shut up! I’ve had enough of this! You’ve pissed me off, you son of a bitch!”

SaturnJoker: Meet Ann’s Persona, Carmen.

New Persona: Carmen

Origin: France (fiction)

Persona 5 Original

Fictional Romani dancer from a novel of the same name by Prosper Merimee. Known for being a femme fatale and smoking a lot.

SaturnJoker: Ann grabs a guard’s sword and uses it to cleave her fake in half.

obs64 2020-08-23 10-20-55-49

SaturnJoker: The “guard captain”, also known as Belphegor, is our mini-boss for this run. Ann stands in a very… strange pose that’s likely to give her some serious back issues in the future. In combat, she uses whips and SMGs - a direct reference to the heroine of Shin Megami Tensei I.

SaturnJoker: Belphegor is weak to fire, and being a mini-boss rather than an actual boss means we can knock him down and get an All-Out Attack on him for free.

SaturnJoker: He responds by casting Magaru, which Ryuji is weak to. This is one of the problems I have with Persona 5 - if this was Persona 1 or Persona 2, we’d just change Ryuji’s Persona to something not weak to wind.

SaturnJoker: I didn’t capture it, but this fight taught me something I didn’t know about how guns work in this game. Guns do more damage the more shots you fire. For Joker’s gun, the first shot did 11 damage and the final one did 88. This means that Morgana’s gun is objectively the worst because it scales the same as Joker’s but has fewer shots.

Ann: “Wait!”

Skull: “Why’d you come here, man!? And more importantly, how!?”

Morgana: “Hey! Is that how you speak to a woman?”

SaturnJoker: SIMP ALERT!

SaturnJoker: In the base game, these forward-facing portraits didn’t exist, and I swear something looks kinda off with Ann’s masked portraits.

Panther: “Wait, what is this thing? Is it alive? How can it talk? And… where in the world are we!?”

Morgana: “J-Just calm down. Everything’s going to be okay; don’t worry.”

Panther: “How am I supposed to calm down!?”

SaturnJoker: Honestly, I don’t know, other than that the character designer was horny. Ann’s outfit is probably the least practical of all of the Fresh Princes: it has a tail for no reason, is bright red, and just… yeah no. Even Joker’s outfit is kinda pushing it with that cape. Ryuji’s the only one who looks like he’s ready for thievery.

Panther: “Ugh, what’s with this!?”

Morgana: “Well, I’m stumped… a search party will be coming for us soon.”

Morgana: “There’s no time to explain. We don’t have a choice. Let’s retreat for now!”

Skull: “We were just gettin’ fired up, and you had to go and get in the way… rgh, fine… here, gimme your arm.”

Ryuji: “Looks like we made it back - hey, are you okay?”

Ann: “Well, pretty much… wait, I lied. I’m still confused about all of this.”

Morgana: “You may be safe now, but a lot sure did happen back there… at any rate, we stand out too much here. Let’s relocate to a safer spot.”

Ann: “Whichever’s not carbonated.”

Ryuji: “Uh, they’re both actually.”

Ann: “Then…”

Morgana: “What about me?”

Ryuji: “Huh? But you’re a cat.”

Morgana: “Have you calmed down, Lady Ann?”

Ann: “Um… Morgana, right? I really am talking to a cat… this feels so strange… oh, sorry! You’re not a cat, right?”

Morgana: “It’s only natural that you’re confused. Demanding that you understand all of this after what you went through is asking too much.”

Ann: “Honestly, I still can’t believe what happened… and that power, my Persona…”

Morgana: “It’s the will of your rebellion, Lady Ann. With it, you’ll be able to fight in that other world.”

SaturnJoker: I feel like letting Hashino have a Blu-Ray disc worth of space was too much. He just kinda crams text in for the hell of it.

Ann: “So if what you told me is true, we can make Kamoshida have a change of heart, right? Is it really possible? Can we actually force him to confess his crimes?”

Ryuji: “The volleyball team’s keepin’ quiet about this, while teachers and parents turn a blind eye.”

Ryuji: “If guys like us try and complain, they’re just gonna shoot us down. Goin’ all in on this plan is the only choice we got.”

Ann: “Then let me help too. I want to make him pay for what happened to Shiho. He just keeps going like nothing happened, even after what he did to her… I’ll never forgive him.”

Ryuji: “Wait, did you just say ‘let me help’? You mean you want us to take you along?”

Ann: “Don’t act like I’m going to drag you down. Weren’t you watching? I can fight too.”

Ryuji: “Hey… what should we do?”

Morgana: “I agree as well. We are lacking in manpower, after all. Don’t worry, I’ll protect her.”

Ann: “Even if you said no, I’d just go in alone.”

Ryuji: “Oh right, she can go in by herself… I guess it’d be more dangerous turnin’ her down. Rgh… fine.”

Ann: “Then it’s decided. Well, I hope we get along!”

Ann: “I’m going to make Kamoshida atone for what he did. Not just for Shiho’s sake… but for everything he’s done.”

Ann: “I won’t let any more people suffer because of him. I’ll do whatever it takes!”

SaturnJoker: I really, really wish they’d removed the extraneous Sae cutscenes from Royal. Like, imagine Paper Mario 64 (or Thousand Year Door) if they just had random Peach cutscenes for no reason.

SaturnJoker: Ann is the reason that the Pixie we automatically picked up will be useful. However, I might try a different strategy with that Pixie assuming we can fuse Personas already that should put us slightly ahead of schedule - it’s a strategy that would only work with the extra money you get from having a P5 save.

Ann: “Hey, give me your number and chat ID. And, um…”

Ann: “I’ll be counting on you, then. Same goes for you, Morgana.”

Morgana: “The pleasure is all mine, Lady Ann.”

Morgana: “What a kind girl… such admirable consideration for others… and the innocence to cast herself into the jaws of death to achieve her goal…”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I hate Morgana so much.

Morgana: “She cares about her friends, and she’s beautiful to boot… what a girl! She’s captured my heart…”

Ryuji: “You know, it’d be better if this group could get together quick from now on…”

Morgana: “True. Our best option would be to make a secret hideout where we could discuss these things.”

Ryuji: “A hideout, huh? I like the sound of that.”

Morgana: “The school rooftop would work. It seems like nobody goes up there. For the time being, that will make the perfect hideout.”

Morgana: “I can’t contact you from inside a Palace, so I’ll stay in this world. That being said, I’ll need someone to take care of me.”

Ryuji: “…This’s all you. There’s no way I can at my place.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Let me tell you something. When I was recording this, and I saw that line from Ryuji, I was like “Oh right, because his dad owns a sushi restaurant” and then I realized that no, that’s Eikichi. I wish they’d hurry up with the Eternal Punishment translation.

Ryuji: “Well, now we have our hideout, so let’s meet there tomorrow!”

Morgana: “Okay! Let’s go look at my new residence for this world!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Even if you’ve never played Persona 5 before, there’s a decent chance you’ve seen fanart of Tae Takemi here. She’s consistently one of the most popular characters and considered by some to be the best girl. As a result, she gets a TON of fanart.

Sojiro: “Hey, lay off the customers. Sorry if he was rude, doctor.”

Tae: “…I don’t mind.”

Sojiro: “Come back again. Phew… that’s it for today.”

Sojiro: “Oh, that customer just now? She’s the head doctor over at that clinic down the street. Rumor has it she gives pretty crappy examinations, and sells some weird homemade medicines on top of that.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: The medicine is called femdom, and overdoses of it cause conditions like Monster Girl Quest. In fact, I am VERY surprised no one has done fanart of Tae as Alice.

Sojiro: “At least, that’s what I’ve heard. I haven’t been there myself. They really should just leave her alone. It’s not like she’s getting in the way of their lives…”

Morgana: “Hey are we there yet?”

Morgana: “Is this some kind of abandoned house!?”

Sojiro: “I was wondering why I heard meowing. What did you bring it here for!?”

Sojiro: “Not my problem. Look, this place is a restaurant. Animals are a no-go…”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: It’s like he’s never heard of the myriad of cat cafes in Tokyo. You know, where he is right now. My dentist has a dog he brings to work and I feel like if that’s got approval, a cat is nothing.

Sojiro: “Though I guess you might stay on good behavior if you’ve got a pet to take care of… fine…”

Sojiro: “But keep it quiet when we’re open for business. And don’t let it roam downstairs, or I’ll toss it out.”

Sojiro: “Oh, and I’m not gonna take care of it. That’s all on you.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I mean, it can’t be any more dangerous than my house, where we have a touch-controlled stovetop that the cat can jump onto and has turned on more than once while sitting on the burners.

Morgana: “Was that the ruler of this place? He seemed pretty understanding for someone who keeps you cramped up in this dump.”

Morgana: “Then again, I suppose to normal people I just sound like a meowing cat.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I mean, my cat can talk, it’s just that the only thing he says is “Human! Get me more dry food from the cabinet! That one, right there! That one! Just reach up and get me some! I know I just ate not even half an hour ago, but I want more!” and then he does the whole ASPCA commercial look like he hasn’t eaten in weeks. He sounds kind of like the crows in Dark Souls 1.

Sojiro: “By the way… have you decided on a name? Morgana? Huh… I was hoping I’d get to name it…”

Morgana: “Looks like the chief likes me better than you. And to be honest, this place is heaven compared to Kamoshida’s cells. …Remember how you guys asked me before about what I am?”

Morgana: “To be honest… I don’t remember anything about my birth. I think the Metaverse’s distortions made me lose both my memories and my true form.”

Morgana: “It has to be! I mean, why else would a cat be able to talk like this? There’s no other possible explanation!”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: If you’ve played Persona 4, this will sound very familiar. It was at this point in my original playthrough that I went “He’s just got the same backstory as Teddie, doesn’t he?”

Morgana: “There’s no doubt that the distortions were what caused me to lose my real self. I’m sure that once they’re purged, I’ll finally be able to get that self back…”

Morgana: “And I have a pretty good idea on how to do it, too. That’s why I was in the castle in the first place.”

Morgana: “Let me make myself clear: your taking care of me won’t be for nothing. It’ll be give and take.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Spoilers: Yes it is for nothing.

Morgana: “Due to my knowledgeable and dexterous nature, i have a lot of intel on infiltration tools.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: We’ll see more of this tomorrow. For the record, I went through the entire game the first time without ever using an infiltration tool.

Morgana: “Whoa, I can’t tell you more unless we settle on a deal. In exchange for you keeping me here, I’ll teach you about these tools. How does that sound?”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I vote for dropping him off at a shelter and seeing if we can find Yukiko’s phone number somewhere. Or Elly’s. Or Yukino and Anna’s since Yukino still has her Persona in this timeline. Hell, see if we can drop Ryuji somewhere and get Eikichi back.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: God dammit, John Persona!

Morgana: “I like that answer. Hehehe… then it’s a deal.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Okay, I’d like to point out that she’s interrogating a 17 year old. How many 17 year olds do you know with access to industrial fabricators?

9_2iVBrO_400x400: Morgana’s confidant is one of a handful that we do not need to do anything to advance. It’s done automatically throughout the plot and you will get a guaranteed max rank in it by the end of the game.

Morgana: “I’ll lecture you about the infiltration tools over time. By the way, the power you used in the Palace was seriously amazing. The stronger that power gets, the more reliable it’ll be as a trump card.”

Morgana: “All right, I’m gonna stick with you wherever you go from now on.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I’m just gonna cut the rest of it because it’s the game telling you that you get perks for having confidants ranked up. In reality, only about… maybe half of them give anything we give a shit about.

obs64 2020-08-23 10-33-54-88

Morgana: “You guys send messages to each other with that thing, right? I want in too, so I’m gonna have to ask you to type for me.”

9_2iVBrO_400x400: I like how they made this a dialog prompt, because Morgana is talking and John Persona is just going “Sleep. Sleep. Sleep.” in the background.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: My cat sleeps right next to my head, because he knows that’s an optimal location for shedding so that it’ll trigger my allergies.

9_2iVBrO_400x400: And that does it with yet another day that wouldn’t fucking end. The 16th will be shorter, and then we’ll hopefully get the 17th, 18th, and 19th into one update.

So… is every party member Persona a historical figure or a fictional character in the public domain? This is the weirdest sequel to League of Extraordinary Gentlemen.

Also I’d like to imagine the character designer was showing their ideas and went, “So I’ve been playing this western game called Arkham City and I was thinking… what if Catwoman but red and blonde?”

Kamoshida

They are. I believe all of the party member Personas but one are from Western literature, and the last one is Japanese literature instead. This is pretty much in line with Lupin III, which did mostly the same thing.

That reminds me that I saw a thing on the wiki when I was getting the portrait for Kamoshida that he shows up again in Persona Q 2 (which I’ve never played because I tried Etrian Odyssey once and hated it) as a Superman knockoff who then turns into a furry.

Before this update came out, I was talking to my friend about P5 and how silly it was you had to go to Kamoshida’s Palace three times. Then he reminded me that you have to find the Palace’s treasure, then leave and come back to fight the boss. But we’d both forgotten that Ann also has to awaken her Persona - and everyone knows that awakening a Persona calls for a nice nap afterward - so make that five times.

For years you’ve been asking “How do I make a 100-hour JRPG?” This is a 100-hour JRPG speaking. I’m the game who refused to take away your dungeons and thus destroyed your world. In the past, others have claimed to be 100-hour JRPGs, however that was only if you did all the sidequests and post-game content, and let’s be real here that doesn’t count. If you wish to be a 100-hour JRPG then come, buy all my spinoffs, and follow me. And also deliver all your exposition at least twice.

I’m excited to see why because literally every fan opinion I’ve seen is the exact opposite. Everyone enjoys Motorcycle Justice Kamen Rider Per5ona.

I mean I don’t know if it’s ever confirmed she is in a coma or not he might definitely just be lying.

More or less correct. The Chinese “shujin” stands for Husband, Master, and Host, while the Japanese “shujin” also covers those EXCEPT for husband, where instead shujin is “another’s husband”. A polite way of saying “your husband”.

And so it begins…

L’Amoureux. The Lovers. Unlike the typical Lovers, this card depicts a fued; a love triangle with Cupid’s spiteful arrows inciting love regardless of consequences. This is one of the Tarot cards that are most obviously “corrupted” or “unusual” compared to the standard. Unless you’re okay with being in a polycule in which case go at it. It’s also worth noting that the original card frames the third person as a sort of priest who is marrying the two off; given the context, less so in this Jokerfied version.

I wanna just grab Morganna by the head and just be like “you realize that just because her psyche form is a cat doesn’t mean she IS a cat, right?”

Le Bateleur. The Magician. Sleight of hand trickster, mountebanc, or otherwise. While The Magician represents someone who is coming into their own, discovering their abilities and finding a way to use them for good, Le Bateleur is more of a scoundrel. Not that that’s evil of course, but it’s a more self serving sense of learning what your abilities are. You are learning to build tools to cause problems on purpose. The “corrupt” symbolism here is obvious in the fact that Le Bateleur’s alchemy table is covered in blood.

1 Like

Oh no, Kamen Rider Per555ona!? But that show is terrible! And also…looks really cool… The pieces are coming together. Everything is connected…

1 Like

I just wanted to mention while addressing mail that I found out today there’s an LP of Royal that started just over a week after this one on a different site (I think it’s on SA and it’s on some “lp beach” site I’d never heard of until yesterday) by the person who did the LP of the base game that’s on the archive. I’m not killing this LP even if it competes with theirs because they hate this game for the wrong reasons and aren’t doing a 100% run anyway.

So here’s the fun part. When I did this game the first time, I didn’t know about the whole “every dungeon takes a minimum of 2 days to complete” bit and assumed it was just like P4 where you had to clear every dungeon in a single day if you wanted 100%.

I was incredibly stingy with my SP and barely made it to the cutoff point thinking I’d still have to fight the boss. Thankfully, I didn’t.

Oh, her DESIGN is amazing. It’s the writing (as usual) that’s the problem, but we won’t be seeing her for a few months yet.

1 Like

I think “I’m going to stop because someone else is doing it” is silly. You probably have some unique takes regardless, unless it’s like… Metal Gear Solid Phantom Pain, where there is just a definitive experience you can watch.

Aah, okay.

Also I love that since this is an RPG and a Persona game, I have no idea if you mean in or out of universe months or not. Probably both!